'Environ-mentalization' & earth-based practice
Environ-mentalization & eARTh-based Practice
Eco-practice is s a core strand of my practice in Art Psychotherapy, Counselling / Psychotherapy, supervision and training. It features celebrating and fostering nature and eco-creativity and it involves working creatively with and for Nature. This aligns with Ecotherapy principles and theories. My approach to integrating eco-practice into art therapy (which might be termed 'eARTherapy') features eARTh-based practice, a key aim being to nurture health, eco-creativity, Nature and our reciprocal caring relationship with the rest of nature. This is underpinned by and committed to 'earth caring' values. Elsewhere, I have also used the term "eARTherapy" (Sibbett, 1995, 1997, 1998, 1999, 2001, 2016).
Key components of my eco-practice / eARTh-based practice include:
working with and for nature,
fostering eco-creativity and wellbeing,
co-creating a "therapeutic tetrad",
practitioner, client, art, nature.
commitment to eARTh-caring values,
eARThing our practice, the curriculum and research,
fostering 'environ-mentalization',
infusing our practice with creative intelligence and "ecological intelligence" (McCallum, 2008).
Howard Clinebell (1996, p.1) in his seminal book Ecotherapy: Healing ourselves, Healing the Earth, argues that:
"The most serious, most dangerous health challenge all of us in the human family face is to reverse the planet's continuing ecological deterioration. It is the most profound health issue of all times, from a historical perspective. Why? For the first time in the long human story, our species faces a health challenge that if not resolved will foreclose opportunities to solve humankind's countless other problems, including a multiplicity of health problems. The human species now must be included on the endangered species list. This is the bottom-line health challenge we all face."
"Obviously, if all plant life is destroyed, the humanoid life will follow." (ST:TOS 'The Cloudminders')
Environ-mentalization
I suggest a term "environ-mentalisation" (Sibbett, 2015) - an ecological development of the concept of mentalisation as proposed by Fonagy et al (Fonagy, Gergely, Jurist & Target, 2002). Fonagy has defined mentalization as an imaginative process by which we interpret and can understand other people's mental states, feelings, thoughts etc. (Fonagy & Allison, 2012). Fonagy has researched mentalization and attachment theory and applications in therapy.
Environ-mentalisation. It is suggested that humans need to cultivate our environ-mentalization - our imaginative capacity to interpret and understand our environment and its states, the needs of Nature, the Earth and its living systems. This can develop our caring attachment with the rest of Nature, thus urging action that makes this attachment with our home the Earth more secure and sustainable. This can promote a more caring reciprocal relationship with and for the rest of Nature.
What is our attachment style with the Earth, with Nature?
One measure that can be used to gauge this is the Connectedness to Nature Scale (CNS) (Mayer & McPherson Frantz, 2004). Another measure is the Environmental Distress Scale (EDS) (Higginbotham, Connor, Albrecht et al, 2007).
Eco-practice: eARTh-based practice
Integrating eco-practice into art therapy ("eARTherapy": Sibbett, 1995, 1997, 1998, 1999, 2001, 2002, 2009, 2016) features 'eARTh-based practice', and is an important wider dimension and application within art therapy.
"Natural environments can potentially have direct and indirect effects on emotional processes—directly by activating or reducing emotions, and indirectly by influencing other important processes related to emotions or emotion regulation. Executive functioning and certain aspects of self-regulation are fundamental for emotion regulation, and research indicates that exposure to nature may have a beneficial impact on these functions, for example, by making it easier to think about feelings." (Johnsen, 2011)
Siddons Heginworth (2008) advocates environmental arts therapy and Jones (2012) writes about outdoor art therapy.
It is suggested that "ecological intelligence" (McCallum, 2008), eco-practice (and eARTh-based practice), is vital in therapeutic and related professions and it involves being actively engaged in fostering eco-creativity. "eARTh-based practice" is founded on being committed to an integrative holistic model of wellbeing that embraces various models of healthcare: 'eco-biopsychosocial" (cf. Sibbett, 1997, 1998, 1999, 2001, 2006), ecozoic (Berry, 1992), biopsychosocial (Engel, 1977), biopsychosocial-spiritual dimensions (Sulmasy, 2006) and "biopsycho-ecological" model (Stineman and Streim, 2010: 1035). eARTh-based practice also involves commitment to respecting and promoting diversity and biodiversity.
Carl Jung wrote: "You must go in quest of yourself, and you will find yourself again only in the simple and forgotten things. Why not go into the forest for a time, literally? Sometimes a tree tells you more than can be read in books." (Jung, 2008, p.6).
Berry (2002: 104) proposes that in:
"the emerging ecological age, the age of the growing intercommunion among all the living and nonliving systems of the planet, ... medicine in this context would envisage the earth as primary healer. It would also envisage integration with earth's functioning as the primary basis of health for the human being."
Berry (1992) argues that, in biological terms, the Earth is at the end of the Cenozoic era (industrial severe diminishment of the planet) and needs to transition into what he calls the Ecozoic era; he argues (p.46) that "The arts are beginning to experience this change." Writing of the role of artists in the Ecozoic era, Berry (1992: 46-48) argues that:
"we must understand that the universe is a communion of subjects, not a collection of objects... the best artists are those who carry us deepest into this experience of communion. ... the Earth is primary and the human derivative. ... The first concern in every field of human endeavour must be the integration with the Earth community. … we try to be healthy on a sick planet… If art becomes limited to human processes, or to human imagination, lacking in intimate relationship with the larger natural world, the art field will lose much of its vigor and purpose. We are becoming aware that the extinction of species, the destruction of the rain forests, the devastation of marine life, the isolation of humanity in an Epcot planet is leading us toward a disaster of untold dimension, both as individual art is and as citizens of the universe. … Now we can perceive the universe as irreversible process and recognize that wanton species extinction is a permanent wound in the biological order. … The endowment that we have inherited becomes infinitely precious to the artist, as to every component of the universe community. The artist is integral to this larger process. … the intimacy of the artist with the entire range of earthly affairs must awaken forebodings about the future, and that these very forebodings will inevitably appear in the visual, literary, and performing arts."
Wilson proposes the concept of "biophilia" and he refers to biofilia as an “innate tendency to focus on life and lifelike processes“ (Wilson 1984, p.1) and an “innate emotional affiliation of human beings to other living organisms“ (Wilson 1993, p.31). Heinsch (2012, p.309) comments on Wilson's (1984, 1993) concept of "biophilia" and notes that "According to Wilson's biophilia hypothesis, people have an innate need to associate with the natural world, and this connection can enhance their physical and psychological well-being." Wilson indicated within his biophilia hypothesis that most people living in Western society are likely to suffer from nature deprivation due to a lack of natural stimuli. He advocated contact with natural diversity and order to be essential to normal development.
Eco-practice in Art Therapy - 'eARTherapy'
It is vital to view therapy within an eco-biopsychosocial model, as consistent with the "Health Environmental Integration model" (HEI) (Stineman, 1981) which conceptualises a "functional interaction between the person and the environment by four overlapping spheres: mind, body, physical world, and society. In the HEI model, the health and experiences of any person depend on the health of the environment and vice versa." (p.36).
In such a model, "the health of any person depends on the health of the environment along with other factors" (Lee & Siebens, 2007). This is also consistent with the need to "expand our paradigm of the self to include the natural habitat. ... It's time for an environmentally based definition of mental health." (Roszak, 1996, 2013). Schuster (1992, p.2) cites Conn's (1991, p.73) view that "... we need to broaden our concept of self to include other groups of people and other life forms."
Stineman and Streim (2010: 1035) advocate a "biopsycho-ecological model of health, illness, injury, and disability." Roszak comments that "a growing number of psychologists have begun to place their theory and practice in an ecological context. Already ecopsychology has yielded insights of great value."
"In devastating the natural environment, we may be undermining a basic requirements of sanity: our sense of moral reciprocity with the nonhuman environment. Yet ecopsychology also offers hope. As ecocidal as our behavior may have become, our bond with the planet endures; something within us voices a warning. Ecopsychologists have begun to detect in people evidence of an unspoken grieving for the great environmental losses the world is suffering." (Roszak, 1996, 2013).
Nature joins as a mutual aspect of the therapeutic alliance - thus forming a Therapeutic Tetrad / Quadrad (Sibbett, 2002...). Appropriate use of ritual, rites of passage, and creative liminality, are important (Sibbett, 2005, 2006).
MacKinnon (2014) makes a call for "rewilding" - creating conditions that will support wildlife in all its diversity; "to bring wildness back into all spaces of the planet in whatever ways that we can. Rewilding, MacKinnon suggests, means to support nature’s potential — its capacity to sustain an abundance and variety of life" (Neilson, 2014). Schuster (1992) proposes a "paradigm of environmental ethic growth comprising interrelationships among stages of moral reasoning; the person in relation to nature; and valuation of material wealth as contrasted to valuation of a safe, clean environment" and this model is based on Glew and The Waterloo County Board of Education (1987) and Environmental Ethic (1988).
It is proposed that art therapy needs to work within an "Health Environmental Integration model" (HEI).
Stineman (1981) offers a model of health environmental integration and Schuster (1992) and proposes the need for an environmental ethic, committed to and demonstrating: ecological conscience, a deep ecological role in relation to nature that is underpinned by the values of caring, cooperation and non-violence, and fostering a safe, clean environment. Integrating ecotherapy into art therapy ("eARTherapy" (Sibbett, 1997, 1998, 1999, 2001, 2002, 2009, 2016)) is in alignment with such a paradigm.
Systems theory is relevant, such as Bronfenbrenner’s (1979, 2005) bioecological model with its nested model of the environmental influences on human development. Perhaps more external systems could be added also, such as: a Terrasystem or Gaiasystem - encompassing the world view; the Cosmosystem - encompassing our connection with the universe or cosmos; the Ultrasystem - encompassing that which our material reality is embedded in. This Ultrasystem could parallel the quantum physics concepts developed by Bohm (1995) of the Implicate Order in which the Explicate Order is enfolded. (Sibbett, 1998)
Earth-caring values
As an extension of Dr Schuster's (1990, 1992, 1993) philosophy of nursing care, art therapists and other art and healthcare practitioners are challenged to "expand our definition of caring to include Mother Earth (Schuster, 1990). ... we have a moral obligation to honor earth caring values, not only for our own quality of life and survival but for the well-being of the planet." (Turkel, 2013: 425-426). The practice of art therapy must be committed to "Earth ethics" (McCluney, 1989).This is also consistent with a systemic perspective on healthcare, in which we are committed to "eARTh-caring values" (Sibbett, 1997, 1998, 1999, 2001, 2002, 2009, 2016).
Engaging in eARTh-based practice, eARTh-caring values relate to embracing and valuing our interconnectedness and promoting systemic wellbeing...
Schuster (1992, p.2) argues that Conn (1991)
"proposes a model of ecological responsibility in which the self derives its unique, differentiated identity from its relatedness (connectedness) as a part of the community of living beings on earth. The self in this model does not simply act on the world or get acted upon in a mechanistic paradigm, but rather interacts creatively and dynamically with the world in an ecological, systemic, self-organizing paradigm."
A metaphor of Indra's Net can inform our "eARTh-based practice" (Sibbett, 1997, 1998, 1999, 2001, 2002, 2009, 2016). Indra’s Net symbolises our interwovenness and interdependence in the Cosmos (Capra, 1991: 151).
"Far away in the heavenly abode of the great god Indra, there is a wonderful net which has been hung by some cunning artificer in such a manner that it stretches out indefinitely in all directions. In accordance with the extravagant tastes of deities, the artificer has hung a single glittering jewel at the net's every node, and since the net itself is infinite in dimension, the jewels are infinite in number. There hang the jewels, glittering like stars of the first magnitude, a wonderful sight to behold. If we now arbitrarily select one of these jewels for inspection and look closely at it, we will discover that in its polished surface there are reflected all the other jewels in the net, infinite in number. Not only that, but each of the jewels reflected in this one jewel is also reflecting all the other jewels, so that the process of reflection is infinite"
The Avatamsaka Sutra of Mahayana Buddhism: Indra's Net. (Cook, 1977).
Eco-practice in training: eARThing the curriculum
Dr Schuster (1993) advocated "greening the curriculum" in nursing. This can be applied to the training of art therapists (and indeed all healthcare and arts practitioners and beyond). There is a need for eARThing the curriculum (Sibbett, 1997, 1998, 1999, 2001, 2002, 2009, 2016) - ensuring it is consistent with an ecozoic model (Berry, 1992) and infusing learning and teaching with eco-creativity and nature and ensuring that all teaching is founded in an eco-biopsychosocial model and adheres to eARTth-caring values. This also means extending learning and teaching into creative and natural contexts, as appropriate.
Eco-practice in research: eARThing research
Similarly, there is a need for a greening / eARThing of research (Sibbett, 1995, 1997, 1998, 1999, 2001, 2002, 2009, 2016) - infusing it with eco-creativity and nature and ensuring that all research is founded in an eco-biopsychosocial model and adheres to eARTth-caring values.
Eco-practice values: eARTh-caring ethical principles
Values and ethical principles are synthesised from sources such as:
United Nations Mother Earth Day - Harmony with nature
Gaia Psychology - ecoemotional intelligence
Transpersonal Psychology
Dr Eleanor Ann Schuster - holistic nursing
Dr Ross McCluney - earth ethics
References
Berry, T. (1992) Art in the Ecozoic Era. Art Journal, Vol.51, No.2, Art and Ecology (Summer, 1992), pp.46-48.Berry, T. (2002) The Dream of the Earth. Sierra Club Nature and Natural Philosophy, University of California Press.Bohm, D. (1995) Wholeness and the Implicate Order. London: Routledge.Bragg, R. and Atkins, G. (2016) A review of nature-based interventions for mental health care. Natural England Commissioned Reports, Number 204. http://publications.naturalengland.org.uk/publication/4513819616346112Bronfenbrenner, U. (1979) The Ecology of Human Development: Experiments by Nature and Design. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Bronfenbrenner, U. (2005) Making Human Beings Human: Bioecological Perspectives on Human Development. Sage Publications.Capra, F. (1991) The Tao of Physics. London: Flamingo.Clarke, Robert B. (2005) An Order Outside Time: A Jungian View of the Higher Self from Egypt to Christ. Hampton Roads Publishing.Clinebell, Howard (1996) Ecotherapy: Healing ourselves, Healing the Earth, New York, NY: Routledge.Conn, S. (1991) The self-world connection: Implications for mental health and psychotherapy. Women of Power, Spring, pp.71-77.Cook, Francis H. (1977) Hua-Yen Buddhism: the Jewel Net of Indra. University Park: The Pennsylvania State University PressEnvironmental Ethic, North American Association for Environmental Education Nonformal Section Workshop, Orlando, FL, October 14-15, 1988.Fonagy, P., Gergely, G., Jurist, E., Target, M. (2002) Affect Regulation, Mentalization, and the Development of the Self. Other Press.Fonagy, P., & Allison, E. (2012) What is mentalization? The concept and its foundations in developmental research. In N. Midgley & I. Vrouva (Eds.), Minding the child: Mentalization-based interventions with children, young people and their families (pp. 11–34). Routledge/Taylor & Francis Group.Glew, F. and The Waterloo County Board of Education (1987) Five Rs Process: A Curriculum Model for Teaching Environmental Value in Education. Curriculum Report. Ottawa, Ontario: The Waterloo County Board of Education.Heinsch, Milena (2012) Getting down to earth: finding a place for nature in social work practice.International Journal of Social Welfare, 21(3):309-318, July 2012.Higginbotham, N. Connor L. Albrecht G. Freeman S. Agho. K. (2007) Validation of an Environmental Distress Scale. EcoHealth, 3, 245–254..Johnsen, Svein Åge Kjøs (2011) The Use of Nature for Emotion Regulation: Toward a Conceptual Framework. Ecopsychology. October 18 2011, 3(3): 175-185.Jones, V. (2012) Practice Definition: art therapy outdoors, Newsbriefing, June 2012. Jung, C.G. (2008) (Ed. Meredith Sabini) The Earth Has a Soul: C.G.Jung's Writings on Nature, Technology and Modern Life. Berkeley, CA: North Atlantic Books.Lee, Laura W. and Siebens, Hilary (2007) Geriatric Rehabilitation. (Chapter 12, pp.301-346) In: J. LoCicero, R.A. Rosenthal, M.R. Katlic, and P. Pompei (Eds) A Supplement to New Frontiers in Geriatrics Research. New York, NY: American Geriatric Association. http://newfrontiers.americangeriatrics.org/chapters/s1chapter12.html?title=RehabilitationMacKinnon, J. B. (2014) The Once and Future World. Toronto: Vintage Canada.Mayer, F. Stephan and McPherson Frantz, Cynthia (2004) The connectedness to nature scale: A measure of individuals’ feeling in community with nature. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 24 (2004) 503–515. McCallum, I. (2008) Ecological Intelligence: Rediscovering Ourselves in Nature. Golden, CO: Fulcrum Publishing.McCluney, R. (1989) Earth ethics - what is it? Earth Ethics Research Group, Inc., 15 December 1988, and Earth Ethics Forum, Summer 1989, Vol. 1, No. 1, Earth Ethics Research Group, Inc., pp. 5-11.Neilson, L. M. (2014) Rewilding Canada: An interview with J.B. MacKinnon. Land Lines, the Nature Conservancy of Canada blog. http://www.natureconservancy.ca/en/blog/rewilding-canada-an.htmlRoszak, Theodore (1996, 2013) The Nature of Sanity. Psychology Today, January 01, 1996 - last reviewed May 02, 2013.http://www.psychologytoday.com/articles/199601/the-nature-sanityRust, M.J. and Totton. N (Eds) (2011) Vital Signs: psychological responses to ecological crisis. London: Karnac. Schuster, E.A. (1990) Earth Caring. Advances in Nursing Science, 13(1): 25-30.Schuster, E.A. (1992) Earth Dwelling. Holistic Nursing Practice, 6(4): 1-9.Schuster, E.A. (1993) Greening the curriculum.J Nurs Educ., Oct;32(8):381-3.Sibbett, C.H. (1992) Art Journals. Unpublished.Sibbett, C.H. (1995) The Green Man of the Spiral. Art form, NIGAT Summer School.Sibbett, C.H. (1997) Creative Connections in Verbal and Non-Verbal Therapeutic Approaches. Presentation at Fifth Art Therapy Summer School, Northern Ireland Group for Art as Therapy. 19 Aug. 1997. Belfast: NIGAT.Sibbett, C.H. (1998) The Shimmering Symbol and the Search for the Self. Workshop at Sixth Art Therapy Summer School, Northern Ireland Group for Art as Therapy. Aug. 1998. Belfast: NIGAT.Sibbett, C.H. (1999) Circling the Self: Creating a New Alchemy of Sense and Soul. Workshop at Seventh Art Therapy Summer School, Northern Ireland Group for Art as Therapy. 16–20 Aug. 1999. Belfast: NIGAT.Sibbett, C.H. (2001) MSc Art Therapy Handbook. Belfast: Queen's University Belfast.Sibbett, C.H. (2002) MSc Art Therapy Handbook. Belfast: Queen's University Belfast.Sibbett, C.H. (2009) MSc Art Psychotherapy Handbook. Belfast: Centre for Psychotherapy, BHSCT.Sibbett, C.H. (2016) eARTherapy: eARTh-based practice and eARTh-caring values. Monologue.Siddons Heginworth, I. (2008) Environmental Arts Therapy and the Tree of Life. Exeter: Spirits Rest. Stineman, Margaret G. (1981) A model of health environmental integration. Topics in Stroke Rehabilitation, 2001;8:34-45.Stineman, M.G. and Streim, J.E. (2010) The Biopsycho-ecological Paradigm: A Foundational Theory for Medicine. Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation (PM&R), 2(11): 1035-1045.Turkel, M.C. (2013) Caring, Health Policy, and the Community. In: Smith M.C., Turkel, M.C., and Wolf, Z.R. (Eds) Caring in Nursing Classics; An Essential Resource. New York, NY: Springer Publishing Company.Wilson, E.O. (1984) Biophilia: The human bond with other species. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.Wilson, E.O. (1993) Biophilia and the conservation ethic. In: R. Kellert & O. Wilson (Eds) The biophilia hypothesis (pp.31-41). Washington, DC: Island Press.